★ Annual Review 2027 tickets now on sale Get your tickets →

News/Protests & Claims/When Silence Is a Verdict: Deemed Denial Under the Contract Disputes Act
Protests & Claims Brief

When Silence Is a Verdict: Deemed Denial Under the Contract Disputes Act

This article was researched and written by Ask Pub K, drawing on Pub K's curated library of authoritative GovCon documents. It has been lightly edited by Pub K's editors for accuracy and clarity.

MargJohnsonVA | Shutterstock

Every contractor with a pending claim has lived through this moment: sixty days pass, the inbox stays empty, and the contracting officer says nothing. Under the Contract Disputes Act (CDA), that silence constitutes a decision. Congress built a release valve into the claims process precisely so agency inertia can’t trap a contractor’s money indefinitely. It’s called “deemed denial.” Understanding how it works can be the difference between a timely appeal and a forfeited claim.

The Statutory Mechanism

The CDA requires a contracting officer to issue a final decision on a claim of $100,000 or less within 60 days of receipt, or — for larger certified claims — either issue a decision within 60 days or notify the contractor of the date by which one will be issued.[1] If the contracting officer does neither, the failure “is deemed to be a decision by the contracting officer denying the claim and authorizes an appeal or action on the claim as otherwise provided” in the statute.[2] FAR 33.211 codifies the same rule at the regulatory level, confirming that any failure to meet the required time periods “will be deemed a decision by the contracting officer denying the claim.”[3]

Note on the FAR Overhaul: The Revolutionary FAR Overhaul (RFO) model deviation for Part 33 relocates this rule. Legacy FAR 33.211 no longer exists as such in the overhauled Part 33; the deemed-denial and decision-timing requirements now live at FAR 33.205-6, Contracting Officer’s Decision.[4] Thirty agencies — including DoD, GSA, DHS, HHS, VA, DOT, Treasury, and NASA — have already posted their own RFO class deviations adopting this renumbering.[5] DoD buyers operate under a parallel DFARS Part 233 deviation, Class Deviation 2026-O0026 (Revision 1, August 24, 2026).[6] Whether “33.211” or “33.205-6” governs a given claim depends entirely on whether the buying agency has adopted the model deviation — a fact worth confirming before citing either number in a brief.

Why It Matters Tactically

Deemed denial is a right, not an obligation. The contractor may appeal immediately once the statutory period lapses, but nothing requires it to — and a late-arriving actual decision doesn’t retroactively invalidate an appeal already filed from a deemed denial.[7] Boards have also made clear that once jurisdiction vests on an appeal from a deemed denial, the contracting officer cannot divest the tribunal of jurisdiction by belatedly issuing — or even withdrawing — a decision.[8]

But patience has limits. A deemed denial still starts the clock for purposes of the CDA’s six-year statute of limitations on filing suit, and courts have refused to apply equitable tolling where a contractor simply sat on its deemed-denial appeal rights for years.[9] And if the agency names a specific decision date within the original 60-day window, that extension is firm — the CDA provides no right to a second bite.[10]

The Takeaway

Deemed denial protects contractors from indefinite agency delay, but navigating it correctly requires tracking two moving targets: the CDA’s statutory clock and the shifting regulatory citations under the ongoing FAR Overhaul. 

This is exactly the kind of fast-moving, cite-heavy research question Ask Pub K was built to answer.

Regulations and agency deviations change frequently; this reflects the position as of October 9, 2026, including DFARS Class Deviation 2026-O0026, Revision 1.


Footnotes

1. 41 U.S.C. § 7103(f) — decision timing requirements. law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/41/7103 ↩

2. 41 U.S.C. Chapter 71 (Contract Disputes). govinfo.gov — USCODE Title 41, Chapter 71 ↩

3. FAR 33.211, Contracting Officer’s Decision. acquisition.gov/far/33.211 ↩

4. FAR Overhaul Part 33 Deviation Guide, FAR 33.205-6. acquisition.gov/far-overhaul/far-part-deviation-guide/far-overhaul-part-33 ↩

5. FAR Part Deviation Guide (list of adopting agencies). acquisition.gov/far-overhaul/far-part-deviation-guide ↩

6. DFARS Class Deviation 2026-O0026, Revision 1 (Aug. 24, 2026), DARS Part 233. acq.osd.mil — Class Deviation 2026-O0026 ↩

7. Pub K, Contractors May Be Able to Appeal Despite Government’s Delay in Issuing Its Final Decision. pubkgroup.com ↩

8. CBCA No. 2279, Hyatt Side Bar & Associates, Inc. (Feb. 21, 2012). cbca.gov decision ↩

9. Pub K, Bizarre Subcontracting Arrangement Still Subject to CDA’s Statute of Limitations, COFC No. 19-376C, Thomas Nussbaum v. United States. pubkgroup.com ↩

10. Government Contracts Navigator, Lifecycle of a Claim, Part IV: Contracting Officer’s Final Decision. governmentcontractsnavigator.com ↩

Not ready to join? Take the free Pub K Weekly digest.One email. Free. Top industry articles, the community calendar, and the latest job postings.