★ Annual Review 2027 tickets now on sale Get your tickets →

Court Rejects USDA Bid to Dismiss States’ Suit Over Grant Conditions

Several states sued the US Department of Agriculture, challenging the agency’s new grant conditions. The conditions require recipients to follow administration policies on immigration, gender, women’s sports, and diversity, equity, and inclusion. The government moved to dismiss the suit for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and failure to state a claim. The district court of Massachusetts denied the Agriculture Department’s motion to dismiss.

The government contended the states lacked standing because they had not established that the conditions posed a substantial risk to Food and Nutrition Service (FNS) programs. The judge found the states plausibly alleged a substantial risk that the conditions will reach nutrition programs, including SNAP. He cited the Secretary’s directive that they apply to “all awards” and an FNS memo rescinding existing civil rights guidance.

The government also argued the states’ claims alleging violation of the Constitution’s spending clause and the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) failed to state a claim. The court, however, found that the states’ Spending Clause claims survived. The states had plausibly alleged the conditions were unclear, not sufficiently related to a federal interest, and possibly coercive. As to the APA claims, the court found the states had sufficiently alleged that the conditions were arbitrary and capricious and exceeded the agency’s authority.

Massachusetts v. USDA